This is one of the most common questions prospective owners ask and one of the most confidently answered with folklore. The honest position is that the differences exist but are modest, and they are usually outweighed by the individual dog.
What genuinely differs?
Size, most reliably. In most breeds males are larger and heavier than females, sometimes considerably. If you are near the limit of what you can physically manage, that difference matters.
Entire males may mark territory with small amounts of urine, including indoors, and may roam or become distracted when a female nearby is in season. Entire females come into season roughly twice a year, with associated bleeding, behaviour changes and the need to keep them away from males for several weeks.
Both sets of behaviours are substantially reduced by neutering, which is why the practical difference between neutered dogs of either sex is smaller than people expect.
Are there temperament differences?
Widely claimed and weakly supported. Males are often described as more affectionate and straightforward, females as more independent and quicker to mature.
There is some truth to females maturing earlier, which can make them easier to train in the first year. Beyond that, variation between individuals within each sex is far larger than any average difference between them.
Breed and line predict temperament much more reliably than sex does, and how a dog is raised predicts it better still.
Does sex matter for aggression?
Less than commonly assumed. Entire males may show more competitive behaviour towards other males, and this reduces with neutering in many but not all cases.
Female-to-female aggression is less common but tends to be more serious when it occurs, which is why two females in one household is often the trickiest combination.
Human-directed aggression is not meaningfully predicted by sex. It is predicted by fear, pain, poor socialisation and learned behaviour.
What if you already have a dog?
This is where sex genuinely matters. Opposite-sex pairings generally get on more easily than same-sex ones, and two females are frequently the most difficult combination.
Individual temperament still dominates. A confident, sociable dog of either sex usually accepts a new arrival better than a nervous or possessive one.
Rescue centres assess this specifically and will advise on what suits your existing dog, which is more reliable than a general rule.
How does neutering come into it?
It changes the calculation considerably, since most sex-linked behaviours reduce after neutering. Timing matters though, particularly in larger breeds.
Neutering before growth plates close can delay their closure and has been linked in some large breeds with higher rates of joint problems. Many vets now recommend waiting until closer to maturity for large and giant breeds.
For females, spaying eliminates seasons and the risk of pyometra, a serious womb infection that affects a significant proportion of unspayed bitches later in life.
What should actually drive the decision?
The individual dog in front of you. Meet the litter or the rescue dog and judge the animal rather than the label.
If you have a strong preference, follow it, since there is no wrong answer here. But do not pass over a well-matched dog because it is the wrong sex, as buyers frequently do.
Size and any existing dog in the household are the two factors worth weighing seriously. Everything else is largely noise.
What are the health differences?
A few worth knowing. Unspayed females are at risk of pyometra, a serious womb infection that affects a significant proportion of bitches later in life and often requires emergency surgery.
Spaying before the first season substantially reduces mammary tumour risk, though it needs balancing against growth plate timing in larger breeds. Some spayed bitches develop urinary incontinence, which is usually manageable.
Males are prone to prostate problems and testicular tumours if left entire. Discuss timing with your own vet rather than following a general rule, since it varies by breed and size.