Puppies are appealing enough that it is easy to look without seeing. A short physical check takes a couple of minutes and is worth doing on every puppy you consider.
What should the eyes look like?
Clear, bright and fully open, with no discharge, redness or cloudiness. A small amount of clear moisture in the corner is normal; thick or coloured discharge is not.
Both eyes the same, both pupils equal. Watch for squinting or excessive blinking, which indicate discomfort.
What about the nose, ears and mouth?
The nose should be clean, with no thick or coloured discharge and no crusting. Sneezing repeatedly is worth noting.
Ears clean inside, pale pink, with little wax and no strong smell. A puppy shaking its head or scratching its ears may have mites, which are common in litters.
Gums pink and moist. Teeth clean and correctly aligned, with the top and bottom meeting reasonably. Significant misalignment can cause problems later.
What should the body feel like?
Rounded but not distended. A pot-bellied appearance with visible ribs elsewhere frequently indicates a heavy worm burden.
Run your hands over the puppy. The coat should be soft and clean, with no bald patches, scabs, crusting or excessive scratching.
Check for lumps, particularly a soft swelling at the navel, which may be an umbilical hernia. Small ones are common and often need no treatment; ask about it.
In male puppies, ask whether both testicles have descended, since a retained testicle needs surgery later.
What should you look for at the back end?
Clean, with no staining or soreness around the tail, which would suggest diarrhoea. Look at the bedding too rather than only the puppy.
Diarrhoea in a litter is worth taking seriously, since it can indicate parasites or infection.
How should the puppy move and breathe?
Watch it walk and run. Movement should be even, with no limping, stiffness or reluctance to bear weight.
Breathing should be quiet and effortless. Noisy breathing, snorting or laboured effort at rest is a genuine concern, particularly in flat-faced breeds where it indicates airway problems that persist for life.
What about behaviour?
An awake puppy should be alert, curious and willing to investigate. Puppies sleep a great deal, so some being asleep means nothing.
A puppy that is lethargic when the others are playing, that seems disconnected, or that does not respond to sound, is worth asking about. Congenital deafness affects some breeds.
What should you do afterwards?
Arrange your own veterinary examination within the first few days, which most health guarantees require in any case.
Raise anything you noticed with the breeder at the time rather than afterwards, since a good breeder will want to know and may already be aware.
Should you see the whole litter?
Yes, and it is informative beyond your own puppy. A litter where several puppies show the same problem points to something affecting the whole group.
Coughing, diarrhoea or eye discharge across a litter suggests infection or poor conditions, whichever individual you were shown.
What if the breeder has already had them vet checked?
Good practice, and ask to see the report rather than accepting the summary. Note which practice did it and what was found.
It does not replace your own examination in the first few days, which most health guarantees require in any case.
What should you not worry about?
A slightly smaller puppy that is otherwise bright, active and feeding well, which usually catches up.
Sleeping heavily, which puppies do for most of the day. A little wariness of a stranger, which is normal at seven weeks.
Minor umbilical hernias, which are common and frequently resolve or need only a small procedure at neutering. If you are unsure about anything you find, say so at the time and ask the breeder to have it checked before collection.
None of this replaces a veterinary examination, and it does mean you arrive at that appointment already knowing what to mention.