Puppy farming is commercial breeding that prioritises volume over welfare, and the puppies it produces frequently arrive with health problems, behavioural difficulties and a mother who has never left a shed. The signs are recognisable if you know them.
What are the warning signs before you visit?
Several breeds available from the same seller, or several litters at once. Puppies consistently available whenever you ask, rather than occasional planned litters.
A reluctance to give a full address, or a suggestion of meeting somewhere convenient such as a car park, a service station or your own home. This is the single clearest signal and it exists specifically to stop you seeing where the dogs live.
Pressure to pay a deposit before visiting, urgency about other interested buyers, or unwillingness to answer questions in writing. Adverts with stock-looking photographs, or the same photographs appearing under different sellers.
What should you see at the visit?
The puppy with its mother, in the place it was born. This is a legal requirement under Lucy's Law and the most important thing you will check.
The mother should interact with the puppies, look well, and be relaxed with the breeder. A mother who is fearful, in poor condition, or reluctant to come near her litter is a serious concern.
Ask to see where the puppies sleep and spend their time. Being shown puppies in a kitchen while never seeing the rest of the property is a common tactic.
What are the warning signs at the visit?
A mother who does not seem bonded with the litter, or who appears to be a different dog from the one described. Sellers occasionally borrow a placid bitch to stand in.
Puppies that are dirty, thin, lethargic, coughing, or have discharge from eyes or nose. A strong smell of urine or faeces, or a large number of dogs on the premises.
Puppies that seem frightened of people or have clearly had no handling. A breeder who cannot tell you the puppies' dates of birth, worming dates or what they are being fed.
Why does it matter so much?
Because the consequences last for years. Puppies from these operations frequently arrive with parvovirus, kennel cough, worms or giardia, and veterinary bills in the first weeks can be substantial.
Behavioural problems are equally common. Puppies raised without household exposure before eight weeks miss a critical period, and many struggle with noise, handling and household life permanently.
Breeding dogs kept in these conditions are typically bred repeatedly with no health testing, so inherited conditions pass straight through.
What about puppies sold from a family home?
Dealers rent houses and place puppies in them specifically to look legitimate. Signs include a house with no evidence of dogs living there, no bedding, bowls or toys, and a seller who cannot answer basic questions about the litter.
Ask to visit twice. Dealers rarely accommodate a second visit, whereas a genuine breeder is usually pleased.
What should you do if you suspect one?
Leave without buying, however hard that is. Buying the puppy funds the next litter and keeps the operation running, and the dogs left behind are the ones who suffer.
Report it to the local authority licensing team for the area, since breeders producing several litters a year require a licence. You can also report to the RSPCA or, for Scotland, the SSPCA.
Keep the advert, messages, address and any photographs, since these are genuinely useful to investigators.
What if you have already bought one?
See a vet promptly for a full check, even if the puppy appears well. Tell them where the puppy came from, as it affects what they look for.
Keep all paperwork and correspondence. Consumer law applies to puppy purchases, and trading standards may be able to help.
What about puppy scams?
A related problem worth knowing. These involve adverts for puppies that do not exist, with deposits requested by bank transfer and reasons found to delay meeting.
Warning signs include a seller who will only communicate by message, requests for payment through unusual channels, and stories about transport costs or insurance fees appearing after the deposit.
Never pay anything before visiting in person, and never pay by bank transfer to someone you have not met. Reverse image search on the photographs frequently reveals them in use elsewhere.