This is the area where advice has changed most, and where owners encounter conflicting information. It is worth setting out what the evidence actually shows.
What are the established benefits?
For bitches, spaying eliminates pyometra, which affects a substantial proportion of unspayed bitches and is life-threatening. That alone is a significant benefit.
It substantially reduces mammary tumour risk, with the effect greatest when done before or shortly after the first seasons. Roughly half of canine mammary tumours are malignant.
For males, castration eliminates testicular cancer and reduces benign prostate enlargement, which is common in older entire dogs.
Both prevent unwanted litters, which matters given the number of dogs in rescue.
What are the joint concerns?
Studies in several breeds have found higher rates of cruciate ligament disease, hip dysplasia and elbow dysplasia in dogs neutered before skeletal maturity.
The mechanism is thought to relate to delayed growth plate closure, producing altered joint angles and longer bones.
The effect is most pronounced in larger breeds. In small breeds the association is weak or absent, which is why timing recommendations differ by size.
What about urinary incontinence?
A recognised effect in spayed bitches, appearing as leaking while asleep, often months or years after surgery.
It is more common in larger breeds and in bitches spayed very young. Reported rates vary considerably between studies.
It is usually treatable with medication and is manageable rather than serious, but it is a genuine consideration when weighing timing.
What about cancer risk?
This is where the picture is most mixed. Some studies have found higher rates of certain cancers in neutered dogs of specific breeds, including haemangiosarcoma, osteosarcoma and lymphoma.
Others have found neutered dogs live longer on average, which may reflect reduced deaths from other causes including pyometra, roaming-related trauma and reproductive cancers.
The findings are frequently breed-specific and do not generalise. A result in Golden Retrievers does not necessarily apply to a terrier.
How should you interpret conflicting studies?
With caution about generalising. Much of the research is observational, drawn from particular populations, and associations are not the same as causes.
What is reasonably clear is that timing matters more in large breeds, that spaying prevents pyometra and mammary tumours, and that the overall balance differs between individual dogs.
What is not clear is a single answer that applies to every dog.
What should you actually do?
Ask your vet what the evidence says for your breed specifically, and discuss your circumstances: whether the dog lives with an entire dog of the opposite sex, how secure your garden is, whether you can manage seasons.
Weigh a certain benefit such as eliminating pyometra risk against an uncertain association reported in one breed study.
Is there a middle route?
Timing is the main lever. Delaying until skeletal maturity in larger breeds captures most of the benefit while avoiding the joint concerns associated with early surgery.
For bitches, ovary-sparing approaches and keyhole techniques exist, and for males a reversible implant allows a trial. Discuss what your practice offers.
What questions should you ask the vet?
What the evidence says for your specific breed, and whether they would recommend a particular age. Whether keyhole spaying is offered.
What the practice's own experience has been with your breed, since vets see patterns locally that do not always appear in published studies.
Whether delaying carries practical difficulties in your circumstances, such as an entire dog of the opposite sex at home or an insecure garden.
Does neutering affect lifespan?
Several large studies have found neutered dogs live longer on average than entire ones. That finding is frequently cited and needs interpreting carefully.
Part of the difference likely reflects avoided deaths from pyometra, reproductive cancers and roaming-related road traffic accidents, rather than a direct effect on ageing.
It also reflects that neutered dogs may be owned by people who seek veterinary care more readily, which is difficult to separate out in observational data.