Rescues want the adoption to work as much as you do, so questions are welcomed. Knowing which ones to ask is the difficult part.
What should you ask about history?
How the dog came to be there: surrendered, stray, seized or returned. Whether the previous owner provided any information.
How long it has been with them, and whether it has been in a kennel or a foster home throughout.
Whether it has been adopted and returned before, and if so why. This is important and rescues should answer honestly.
Where nothing is known, say so is a better answer than a confident story, and good rescues are clear about the difference.
What should you ask about behaviour?
Not whether the dog is friendly, which everyone says. Ask what it is actually like day to day.
How it is with other dogs, on and off lead. With cats, if that matters. With children of different ages, and whether it has actually met any.
How it copes with being left alone, and for how long it has been tested. This is the most commonly under-asked question and the most common reason adoptions struggle.
How it travels in a car, how it walks on a lead, and how it behaves at the vet and when groomed.
Whether it has ever growled, snapped or bitten, and in what circumstances.
What should you ask about health?
What veterinary treatment it has had and what is known about its health. Whether it is neutered, vaccinated, microchipped and up to date on parasite treatment.
Any ongoing condition, medication or dietary requirement, and what that costs.
Whether the rescue can provide veterinary records, and whether any condition would be excluded from insurance.
What should you ask about the practicalities?
Whether you can visit more than once, and whether you can take the dog for a walk.
Whether they will do a meeting with your existing dog, and where. Whether there is a trial or foster-to-adopt arrangement.
What the fee covers, what support is offered afterwards, and what happens if it does not work out.
What answers should reassure you?
Specific ones. A rescue that says the dog is nervous of men in hats, needs a fortnight to settle and pulls badly on the lead knows the dog.
Willingness to describe problems rather than only positives. Rescues that disclose difficulties are the ones you can trust on everything else.
What should concern you?
Everything described as perfect. Reluctance to answer about behaviour or bite history. Pressure to decide today.
No home check, no contract, and no arrangement for taking the dog back.
What should you tell them?
Everything relevant, including the awkward parts: hours the house is empty, a nervous child, an intolerant resident cat, a small garden.
Rescues are trying to match rather than to catch you out, and an accurate picture produces a better dog.
Understating your working hours is the most common misrepresentation and the one most likely to produce a failed adoption.
What should you ask about yourself?
Ask them to be frank about whether your circumstances suit the dog. Good rescues will say so, and that conversation is more useful than a diplomatic answer.
Ask what kind of home they think this dog needs, and listen to whether it sounds like yours.
What should you ask about the future?
Whether they will take the dog back at any point, and whether there is any support if things become difficult.
Whether they can put you in touch with the fosterer after adoption, which is frequently the most useful contact you will have.
Should you ask to speak to the fosterer?
Yes, where the dog is in a foster home. The fosterer has lived with it and will tell you things a summary cannot.
Ask what the dog does in the evening, whether it settles, what wakes it, how it greets visitors and what it is like on a wet Tuesday.
Those ordinary details predict daily life far better than any assessment form.