Most people choose the puppy that comes to them first, or the one with the most appealing markings. Neither is a good basis for a fifteen-year relationship.
Why does temperament matter more than looks?
Because you will live with the temperament daily and stop noticing the markings within a fortnight.
Within a single litter there is considerable variation: confident and cautious, busy and calm, independent and clingy. Those differences persist.
Matching temperament to your household matters far more than colour, and it is the part buyers most often ignore.
Why should you listen to the breeder?
Because they have observed these puppies every day since birth and you will see them for an hour or two.
A good breeder knows which puppy is bold, which is sensitive, which recovers quickly from a startle and which holds a grudge about the vacuum cleaner.
Tell them honestly about your household: children, other pets, working hours, experience, how active you are and what you want to do with the dog. Then take their recommendation seriously.
Some breeders allocate puppies themselves rather than letting buyers choose, which is a sign of a careful operation rather than an imposition.
What should you observe?
How the puppies interact with each other. Which one instigates play, which one is repeatedly flattened, which takes itself off to sleep.
How they respond to you. A puppy that approaches, investigates and then wanders off is showing normal confidence. One that hides and will not emerge is worth noting.
How they recover from something mildly startling, such as a dropped set of keys. Recovery speed matters more than the initial reaction.
Whether they are comfortable being picked up and gently handled, and how they respond to being turned onto their back briefly.
Should you avoid the extremes?
Generally yes, for most households. The boldest puppy in the litter is frequently the most demanding, and the most confident puppies suit experienced owners.
The shyest puppy is frequently the hardest work of all, needing careful socialisation to avoid lasting fearfulness. People choose it out of sympathy and are often unprepared.
A middle-of-the-road puppy suits most families, which is unromantic advice and reliably good.
Does sex matter?
Less than most people assume, and individual variation within each sex is far greater than the average difference between them.
Practical considerations include seasons in an entire bitch, and whether you already have a dog, since opposite-sex pairs frequently coexist more easily.
What about the runt?
A smaller puppy that is otherwise healthy, active and feeding well is usually fine and often catches up.
A puppy that is lethargic, being pushed away from the mother or noticeably failing to thrive is a different matter and should have been seen by a vet.
What if none feels right?
Walk away. It is a fifteen-year decision, and there will be other litters.
What about choosing on markings?
Perfectly reasonable as a tie-breaker between two puppies of suitable temperament, and a poor primary criterion.
Coat colour and markings change as puppies grow, sometimes considerably, so what you choose at seven weeks may look different at a year.
What if you are choosing remotely?
You should not be, since you need to visit. Where a first look happens by video, ask the breeder to film the puppies interacting rather than showing individuals held up to the camera.
Then make the final decision in person, with the breeder's guidance.
What if you are told the puppy has been allocated?
Common with careful breeders, who match puppies to homes themselves. It is a sign of a good operation rather than an insult.
Ask why they chose that puppy for you. The reasoning is usually sound and tells you a great deal about how well they know the litter.
Take the breeder's advice, avoid the extremes unless you specifically want what they bring, and remember that you are choosing a companion rather than a photograph.