This is one of the few aspects of puppy buying with a clear legal answer, and a breeder willing to breach it has told you everything you need to know.
What is the legal position?
In England, licensed breeders may not sell or transfer a puppy under eight weeks of age, and the puppy must be seen with its mother.
Equivalent provisions apply across Britain. Any offer to let a puppy go at six or seven weeks is a breach and a reason to walk away.
The puppy must also be microchipped and registered before it leaves.
What do puppies learn in those weeks?
Bite inhibition, which is learned through play with littermates. A puppy that bites too hard is yelped at and the game stops, and it gradually learns to moderate the force of its jaws.
Dog-to-dog social skills: reading body language, taking turns, backing off, tolerating being climbed on. These are learned from other dogs and are difficult to teach afterwards.
Frustration tolerance, as the mother begins weaning and stops meeting every demand immediately.
General resilience, through gradual exposure to novelty in a secure setting with the mother present.
What happens if a puppy leaves too early?
Studies comparing puppies separated at different ages have consistently found more behaviour problems in those removed early.
Reported issues include excessive barking, fearfulness, reactivity to noise, possessiveness, attention-seeking and harder mouthing.
Puppies removed before six weeks are at particular risk. The effects are not inevitable and the odds shift meaningfully.
Is later better?
Up to a point. Many breeders keep puppies until nine or ten weeks, which is fine provided socialisation continues actively.
Beyond that, the risk shifts the other way. The sensitive period for socialisation closes at around sixteen weeks, so a puppy kept in a limited environment until twelve weeks loses valuable time in its new home.
Some breeds are traditionally released later, and some breeders keep a puppy longer for their own assessment. Ask what socialisation is happening during that period.
What about very small breeds?
Toy breeds are sometimes kept until ten or twelve weeks because they are fragile and prone to low blood sugar in early life.
This is a legitimate reason rather than an excuse, provided the puppies are being actively socialised meanwhile.
What should you ask?
When the puppies will be ready and why. What socialisation is planned between now and then.
Whether the mother is still with them and how weaning has gone.
What if a breeder offers earlier?
Decline and reconsider the breeder entirely. It is illegal, it is bad for the puppy, and it indicates an operation prioritising turnover.
Be equally cautious about a puppy advertised as ready now at seven weeks, which is a common feature of illegal selling.
What about older puppies?
Sometimes a breeder has a puppy of four or five months, either run on for assessment or returned. This is not automatically a concern.
Ask why, and what socialisation the puppy has had during that period, since the sensitive window closes at around sixteen weeks.
A well-socialised older puppy from a good breeder can be an excellent option, particularly for owners who would rather skip the earliest weeks.
How do you know the age is genuine?
Ask for the date of birth in writing and check it against the vaccination card and microchip records, which should be consistent.
Very young puppies have visibly different proportions and teeth, and your own vet can give an opinion on approximate age at the first appointment.
A significant discrepancy is worth reporting, since underage sale is both illegal and harmful.
What should you do at collection?
Take a blanket that can pick up littermate scent, and ask for something from the litter's bedding to take with you.
Confirm what the puppy last ate and when, and travel with someone else so one person can sit with the puppy.
The weeks in the litter are doing real work that cannot be replicated afterwards. Eight weeks minimum, and a breeder who offers earlier is one to walk away from.