The sensitive period for socialisation runs to roughly sixteen weeks, and a puppy leaving at eight has spent half of it with the breeder. What happened there matters enormously.
Why does the breeder's part matter so much?
Because it covers the earliest and arguably most formative weeks, and it cannot be repeated afterwards.
Puppies raised in a home, surrounded by ordinary domestic activity, arrive already familiar with televisions, hoovers, doorbells, cooking and coming and going.
Puppies raised in an outbuilding or kennel arrive having experienced none of it, and every ordinary household event is novel and potentially frightening.
That difference persists, and owners of kennel-raised puppies frequently spend months catching up.
What should a good breeder be doing?
Raising the litter indoors in a busy part of the house, so household noise is background rather than novelty.
Handling every puppy daily from early on: holding, touching paws, ears and mouths, weighing, and general gentle contact.
Introducing different surfaces to walk on: carpet, tile, lino, grass, wood, something slightly unstable.
Playing recorded sounds at gradually increasing volume, including traffic, fireworks, thunder and household appliances.
Introducing novel objects regularly: cardboard boxes, tunnels, umbrellas, wheeled items, things that move and make noise.
What about people?
Visitors of different ages and appearances, where hygiene allows. Men and women, children if the breeder has access to them safely, people in hats and coats.
Many breeders limit visitors before vaccination for good reason, and use household members and a controlled number of guests instead.
Ask specifically whether the puppies have met children, since this is the gap most commonly reported later.
What else should be happening?
Beginning toilet training by providing a separate toileting area away from the sleeping space, which makes house training considerably easier.
Short separations from the litter, which begins building tolerance for being alone.
Early crate or pen exposure with the door open. Car journeys, even very short ones, for some breeders.
Introducing grooming: a soft brush, nails handled, a bath in some cases.
What should you ask?
What socialisation programme they follow, since good breeders will describe something structured rather than saying the puppies have been handled a lot.
What the puppies have experienced so far, and what is planned before collection. Whether they will provide a written record.
Several established programmes exist for raising litters, and a breeder who names one is worth taking seriously.
What should concern you?
Puppies raised in a shed, garage, barn or outdoor kennel. Reluctance to describe what has been done.
A litter that is startled by ordinary noise during your visit, or that will not approach a stranger at all.
An answer amounting to the puppies are with their mother and get plenty of fresh air.
Does it vary by breed?
The principles are constant and the emphasis shifts. Guarding breeds particularly benefit from extensive early exposure to visitors, since wariness of strangers is part of the type.
Herding breeds benefit from early habituation to movement and noise, given their sensitivity to both.
Nervous or sensitive breeds need the most careful early work, and a good breeder of such a breed will describe a detailed programme.
What should you do when the puppy arrives?
Continue it immediately rather than pausing while the puppy settles. Ask the breeder what has been covered so you can target the gaps.
Carrying the puppy out before vaccination is complete allows most of the remaining work to happen on time.
How much difference does it make?
A great deal, and it shows up months later. Owners of well-socialised puppies describe dogs that take fireworks, visitors and hoovers in their stride.
Owners of kennel-raised puppies frequently spend the first year working on things the breeder could have covered in a fortnight. Ask for the socialisation record in writing, which good breeders are usually pleased to provide.
Of everything you can ask a breeder, this is the question that most predicts what the dog will be like to live with, and it is the one buyers most often forget.