Resource guarding is common, entirely normal from the dog's point of view, and one of the most frequently mishandled behaviours in dog ownership.
What does it look like?
Behaviour intended to keep something valuable. It escalates through stages, and the early ones are easy to miss.
Eating faster as someone approaches. Freezing over an item. Turning the body between you and the object. A hard stare, whale eye where the whites show, or a stiffened posture.
Then lip curling, growling, snapping and, if the warnings are ignored or punished, biting.
Dogs guard food, chews, toys, stolen items, beds, sofas, doorways and sometimes people.
Why do dogs do it?
Because keeping hold of valuable resources is adaptive behaviour. A dog that gave up food readily would not have fared well historically.
It is not dominance and it is not the dog challenging your position. It is anxiety about losing something, and the anxiety is what needs addressing.
Some dogs are genetically more predisposed. Dogs that experienced scarcity or competition, including many from rescue backgrounds, are more likely to guard.
Why does taking things away make it worse?
Because it confirms the dog's concern. If human hands reliably remove valuable things, the dog has excellent reason to defend them.
The old advice to take a puppy's bowl away while it eats, or to put a hand in the food, is now understood to create guarding rather than prevent it.
Chasing a dog that has stolen something teaches it that possession leads to pursuit, which produces faster swallowing and more determined guarding.
What is the better approach?
Making your approach predict something good rather than a loss.
Walk past a dog eating and drop something better into the bowl without stopping. Over time your approach predicts an upgrade rather than a threat.
For items, trade rather than take. Offer something better, and when the dog releases, frequently give the original item back so releasing does not always mean loss.
Teach drop it and leave it properly as everyday cues, so the mechanism exists before it is needed.
What management is essential?
Feed the dog somewhere it will not be disturbed, behind a closed door or a gate. Do not give high-value chews when people are moving around.
Pick up items likely to be stolen. If the dog takes something, avoid a confrontation: scatter food elsewhere and pick the item up once the dog moves away.
Never reach into a guarding dog's space to retrieve something, and never punish a growl, which removes the warning without changing the feeling.
When is it urgent?
Where there are children in the household, this needs professional help immediately rather than being managed alone.
Children move unpredictably, approach at face height and do not read warning signals. Guarding is one of the more common contexts for serious bites to children.
See a vet first to rule out pain, then a clinical animal behaviourist registered with the Animal Behaviour and Training Council, ideally on veterinary referral.
Can it be prevented in a puppy?
To a degree. Do not take food or items away without giving something better. Do not put hands in the bowl while the puppy eats.
Instead, walk past and drop something better in, so your approach predicts an upgrade. Teach drop it and leave it as trading games from the start.
Feed somewhere the puppy will not be disturbed, and teach children from day one that the dog is left alone while eating.
When does it become urgent?
Where a bite has occurred, where there are children in the household, or where the guarding is escalating.
Also where the dog guards the owner from other people or pets, which is a specific pattern that needs professional handling rather than management alone.
What does treatment involve?
Structured work with a behaviourist, typically combining management, changing the dog's expectation of human approach, and teaching alternative behaviours.
It is gradual and specific to the individual dog, which is why generic advice found online frequently makes guarding worse rather than better.