Anti-bark collars are widely sold and widely criticised. The short answer is that some suppress barking in the short term, and that is not the same as solving the problem.
What types exist?
Static or electronic collars, which deliver an electric shock when the dog barks. Citronella collars, which spray a burst of scent. Ultrasonic devices, which emit a high-pitched sound. Vibration collars, which buzz.
All work on the same principle: applying something unpleasant when the dog barks, so it barks less.
What is the legal position in the UK?
Electronic shock collars have been banned in Wales since 2010, with penalties for use. In Scotland, government guidance has strongly discouraged their use.
In England a ban has been proposed and debated repeatedly over several years without being brought fully into force, and the position has changed more than once.
Because this area has been subject to ongoing legislative proposals, check the current position for your part of the UK rather than relying on a general statement.
Why do behaviour professionals object?
Because barking is a symptom, and suppressing it leaves the cause untouched. A dog barking from fear that is punished for barking is still frightened, and now has a second thing to worry about.
There is also a risk of the dog associating the unpleasant sensation with whatever it was barking at rather than with its own barking. A dog shocked while barking at a passing child may come to associate children with pain.
That association is how suppression turns a noise problem into an aggression problem, and it is the outcome professionals see most often.
Do they work at all?
Static collars frequently reduce barking in the short term, which is why they persist. Citronella works for some dogs and is ignored by others once they habituate.
Ultrasonic devices have limited evidence and many dogs disregard them entirely.
Even where suppression occurs, dogs commonly find another outlet: pacing, destructive behaviour or displacement activity. The underlying arousal has not gone anywhere.
What about the practical problems?
Collars trigger on the barking of other dogs in the household, punishing the wrong animal. They misfire on coughing, whining or collar movement.
They cannot distinguish an excited greeting from a genuine alarm, so a dog is punished for warning you about something.
What should you do instead?
Identify the type of barking, since the effective approach differs entirely between fear, frustration, territorial and demand barking.
Manage the trigger, which frequently produces the fastest improvement. Teach an alternative behaviour. Address arousal through adequate exercise, mental work and rest.
For persistent barking, or where fear or aggression is involved, consult a behaviourist registered with the Animal Behaviour and Training Council.
Is there ever a case for them?
Professional bodies including the major UK welfare organisations advise against aversive collars, and most recommend reward-based approaches instead.
Where barking threatens a tenancy or is causing a legal nuisance, the pressure to find a quick fix is real. Even then, a behaviourist will usually produce a faster durable result than a collar.
What do the welfare organisations say?
Major UK welfare and veterinary bodies advise against aversive training devices, recommending reward-based methods and behavioural assessment instead.
The consistent position is that the risk of behavioural fallout outweighs any short-term reduction in noise, particularly where the barking has an emotional cause.
What about vibration collars?
These sit in a different category, particularly when used as a cue rather than a punishment. A vibration collar used to get a deaf dog's attention is a communication tool.
Used automatically to interrupt barking, it becomes an aversive device with the same drawbacks as the others.
What about bark-activated devices in the home?
Static devices that emit a noise or spray when a dog barks carry the same drawbacks as collars, with the added problem that they punish whichever dog is nearest.
They also fire when nobody is home, meaning an anxious dog is punished repeatedly with no one present to help, which is the worst possible arrangement for separation-related barking.