Back to Training

What Rewards Work Best for Puppy Training?

What Rewards Work Best for Puppy Training?
Dog Guides Editorial 23 July 2026

Reward-based training is straightforward in principle and depends heavily on details most owners are never told: what to use, how much, how often, and when to stop.

What makes a good reward?

Something the puppy genuinely wants, which is decided by the puppy rather than by you. Food works for most, though some are more motivated by a toy or a game.

It should be small, so training does not become a meal. Pea-sized is plenty, and for a small breed considerably less.

It should be quick to eat. Anything requiring chewing breaks the rhythm and loses the puppy's attention.

Why does a hierarchy matter?

Because reward value has to match difficulty. A piece of dry kibble is fine for a sit in the kitchen and hopeless for recall away from another dog.

Build three levels. Ordinary kibble for easy things at home. Something better such as commercial training treats for moderate difficulty. Something exceptional such as chicken, cheese, sausage or liver for anything genuinely hard.

Reserve the top tier so it retains value. If chicken is the background rate, it stops being special.

How do you avoid overfeeding?

Take training food from the daily ration rather than adding it on top. Measure the day's food in the morning and train from a portion of it.

Treats should be around ten per cent of daily intake, and puppy training uses a lot of food, so using the meal ration is the practical solution.

Make pieces tiny. Dogs respond to frequency rather than size, and a puppy will work as hard for a crumb as for a whole biscuit.

What is a marker word?

A sound that tells the puppy precisely which moment earned the reward, bridging the gap between the behaviour and the treat arriving.

Use a short word such as yes, or a clicker. Say it the instant the behaviour happens, then deliver the treat within a second or two.

Charge it first by saying the word and immediately giving a treat, twenty times, until the puppy looks expectant when it hears it.

Precision matters. A marker delivered a second late marks whatever the puppy did next.

Are non-food rewards useful?

Very. Toy-motivated puppies will work hard for a short game of tug, which removes calories from training entirely.

Life rewards are powerful and underused: permission to sniff, the door opening, the lead going on, being released to play. Ask for a sit before each of these and the sit gets reinforced dozens of times a day at no cost.

How often should you reward?

Every single time while learning something new. This is the stage where owners most often under-reward.

Once a behaviour is reliable in a given situation, move to rewarding intermittently and unpredictably. Variable rewards sustain a behaviour more strongly than constant ones.

Return to rewarding every time whenever you increase difficulty or change environment.

Do you have to use treats forever?

No, and this is the usual worry. Treats are used heavily during learning and reduced afterwards, replaced by praise, play and life rewards.

The mistake is fading them too quickly, which is the most common reason a cue that worked at four months stops working at eight.

What if the puppy will not take treats?

Usually a sign of stress rather than fussiness. A puppy that eats happily at home and refuses food in the park is telling you the environment is too much.

Increase distance from whatever is worrying it and try again. A dog that cannot eat cannot learn, so the answer is reducing difficulty rather than finding better treats.

Also check you are not training just after a meal, when food is less appealing.

Does praise work on its own?

For some dogs in easy situations, and rarely for anything difficult. Praise is a useful supplement and a weak primary reward for most puppies.

Use it alongside food rather than instead of it, so that over time praise itself becomes more meaningful through association.