Back to Training

Does Getting Another Dog Help?

Does Getting Another Dog Help?
Dog Guides Editorial 14 April 2026

This is one of the most common suggestions owners receive and one of the riskiest to act on. It sometimes works and it can leave you with two problems.

Why does it usually not help?

Because most separation anxiety involves attachment to a specific person rather than a general dislike of solitude.

A dog that panics because you have gone will still panic with another dog present, since the other dog is not you.

Owners report exactly this outcome regularly: a second dog acquired specifically to help, and the first dog no calmer.

When might it help?

Where the problem is genuinely isolation distress rather than attachment to a person. These dogs are distressed by being alone as such and settle with any company, including a house sitter or another animal.

A behaviourist can distinguish between the two, typically by observing whether the dog settles when left with someone other than the attachment figure.

If the dog is fine when left with a neighbour but panics when genuinely alone, a companion may help. If it panics regardless of who else is present, it will not.

What are the risks?

The most obvious is having two dogs and one still anxious, which doubles the cost and workload without solving anything.

Anxious behaviour can also spread. A new dog that would have been fine may learn to bark and pace by copying, and dogs do pick up behaviours from each other.

Adding a second dog is a significant change to the household, and change is exactly what an anxious dog copes with poorly. Some deteriorate initially.

There is also the possibility of conflict between the dogs, which introduces a separate and more serious problem.

What should you do before deciding?

Test the hypothesis rather than guessing. Arrange for the dog to be left with a friend's dog, or with a sitter's dog, and record what happens.

If the dog settles, that is meaningful evidence. If it does not, you have saved yourself a substantial mistake.

Discuss it with a behaviourist before committing, since they can assess which type of separation problem you are dealing with.

What if you want a second dog anyway?

That is a perfectly good reason to get one, and a different question from whether it will cure the first dog.

If you do, treat the anxiety separately rather than expecting the new arrival to resolve it. Introduce carefully, provide duplicate resources, and give both dogs their own space.

Continue the desensitisation work with the anxious dog, including leaving it alone without the other dog occasionally, so it does not simply transfer its attachment.

What about other animals?

A cat rarely helps, since the relationship is different and cats generally do not provide the reassurance an anxious dog is seeking.

What is the honest summary?

Get a second dog because you want one and have the time, space and money for two. Do not get one as a treatment, since the odds of it working are not good.

What do behaviourists generally advise?

Treating the existing dog's anxiety first, and considering a second dog separately once things are stable.

Adding a dog during active treatment complicates the picture, since you can no longer tell what is helping and what is not.

If a companion is genuinely likely to help, that will still be true in six months.

What is the honest summary?

A second dog is a significant, permanent commitment with a modest chance of helping and a real chance of complicating things.

Test the theory first, involve a behaviourist, and separate the question of whether you want another dog from whether it will fix this one.

What about fostering a dog first?

A sensible middle route for some households, since it gives a genuine trial without a permanent commitment.

Discuss it with a rescue organisation and be honest about the existing dog's anxiety, since they will want to place a suitable companion rather than any dog.