Toilet training is straightforward in principle and demanding in practice, because it depends almost entirely on how consistent you are in the first few weeks.
What is the basic approach?
Take the puppy outside frequently, reward heavily when it performs, and supervise or confine it in between so accidents cannot happen unnoticed.
That is genuinely the whole method. What varies is how rigorously it is applied.
You are not teaching the puppy that indoors is wrong. You are building a habit that outdoors is where this happens, by making sure it happens there far more often than anywhere else.
When should you take the puppy out?
On a schedule rather than waiting for signals, since young puppies give very little warning.
Immediately on waking, after every meal, after any play or excitement, and every forty-five to sixty minutes in between while awake.
Also last thing at night and first thing in the morning, and at least once overnight for a young puppy.
How should you reward it?
Immediately, at the spot, while the puppy is still outside. This is the part most often got wrong.
A treat given back in the kitchen rewards coming indoors rather than toileting outside. The reward has to arrive within a second or two of the puppy finishing.
Use something genuinely good rather than praise alone, particularly in the early weeks. Carry treats in your pocket so you are never without them.
Should you stay outside afterwards?
Yes, for a few minutes. If going indoors always immediately follows toileting, a puppy that enjoys being outside learns to hold on.
Wait, reward, then spend a little time outside before returning. This is a common and easily fixed reason toilet training stalls.
What about supervision?
A puppy that cannot be watched should be somewhere it cannot make a mistake unnoticed: a pen, a crate or a small easily cleaned area.
Most dogs avoid soiling where they sleep, which is why a correctly sized crate helps. Too large and the puppy will use one end and sleep in the other.
Every accident that happens indoors is a repetition that makes the next one more likely, so prevention does more than any correction.
What should you do about accidents?
Say nothing and clean thoroughly with an enzymatic cleaner.
Punishment is the single most counterproductive thing here. A punished puppy does not learn to go outside; it learns not to go in front of you, which produces accidents behind the sofa and a puppy that will not perform on a lead.
If you catch it in the act, interrupt gently with a neutral sound and carry the puppy outside, then reward if it finishes there.
How do you know it is working?
Accidents become less frequent and start happening in predictable circumstances rather than randomly. The puppy begins heading for the door.
Progress is rarely linear, and a regression after a settled period usually means going back a stage for a fortnight rather than starting again.
What should you do at night?
A young puppy will need at least one trip overnight, sometimes two. Keep it functional: minimal light, no talking beyond quiet praise, no play, straight back to bed.
Setting an alarm before the puppy wakes and cries is worth doing in the first fortnight, so crying does not become the way it gets your attention.
What about signalling?
Most puppies begin heading towards the door once the habit forms, and you can encourage this by always using the same exit.
Some owners teach a bell hung by the door, ringing it themselves each time they take the puppy out until the puppy tries it. It works well, though some dogs then ring it to go and play, so be prepared for that.
What equipment helps?
A crate or pen sized so the puppy can stand, turn and lie stretched out, but not so large it can use one end and sleep in the other.
An enzymatic cleaner, bought before the puppy arrives rather than after the first accident. A treat pouch or a pot of treats by the back door.
Easily washable flooring or a washable mat in the area the puppy spends most time, which removes a good deal of stress from the process.