Pet food packaging is marketing first and information second. A few parts of the label are legally defined and genuinely useful, and learning to find them cuts through most of the noise.
What does complete actually mean?
This is the most important word on the packet. A food labelled complete contains everything a dog needs in the correct proportions and can be fed as the only food.
Complementary means it does not, and is intended to be fed alongside something else. Many raw products, toppers and some premium-looking foods are complementary, and feeding one as a sole diet produces nutritional deficiency over time.
The label will also state which life stage the food is formulated for: puppy, adult, senior, or all life stages.
What does the ingredient list tell you?
Ingredients are listed by weight in descending order, so the first few make up most of the food. A named meat first is generally a good sign.
Watch for splitting, where one ingredient is divided into several entries to push it down the list. A food listing maize, maize gluten and maize flour separately may contain more maize than the meat listed first.
Also note that fresh meat is listed at its wet weight, which is mostly water. Once cooked, chicken listed as the first ingredient may contribute far less than it appears to. Meat meal is already dried, so a smaller listed weight represents more actual protein.
What do the percentages mean?
The analytical constituents panel gives protein, fat, fibre, ash and moisture. These are useful for comparison but only between foods of similar moisture content.
Comparing a dry food at eight per cent moisture with a wet food at eighty per cent is meaningless without adjusting. To compare properly, work out the figure on a dry matter basis by dividing the nutrient percentage by the dry matter percentage.
Higher protein is not automatically better. What matters is quality and digestibility, which the label does not tell you.
Which terms are meaningless?
Premium, super premium, gourmet, natural and holistic have no legal definition in pet food and can be applied to anything.
Human grade is frequently misused. Ancestral, biologically appropriate and species appropriate are marketing frameworks rather than nutritional standards.
Photographs of vegetables and cuts of meat on the front tell you nothing about the proportions inside, which are on the back.
What about derivatives and by-products?
These sound unappealing and are not automatically poor. Animal derivatives can include organ meats, which are nutritionally excellent and are what a dog would eat naturally.
The problem is vagueness rather than the ingredient itself. Meat and animal derivatives without a named species means the manufacturer can vary the source between batches, which matters for a dog with sensitivities.
A named source such as chicken meal is more informative than an unnamed one.
What else should you check?
The feeding guide, which gives a starting amount by weight, and the batch number and best before date. Keep a note of the batch in case of a recall.
Look for a statement that the food meets FEDIAF nutritional guidelines, which is the European standard for complete pet foods.
How should you choose between foods?
Pick a complete food appropriate to the life stage, from a manufacturer that employs nutritionists and runs feeding trials, then judge it on the dog. A dog doing well has a good coat, firm stools, steady weight and normal energy.
Price correlates loosely with quality and not reliably. The most expensive food is not necessarily the best one for your dog.
How do you compare two foods fairly?
Work out the cost per day rather than per bag, since calorie density varies and a cheaper food often needs feeding in larger amounts. A more expensive bag can work out cheaper daily.
Compare protein and fat on a dry matter basis if the moisture contents differ. Divide the nutrient percentage by the dry matter percentage to get a figure you can compare directly.
Then check the feeding guide for your dog's weight in both, which tells you far more about relative energy density than the front of the packet does.