Back to Care

Is Crate Training Cruel?

Is Crate Training Cruel?
Dog Guides Editorial 13 May 2026

Crates divide opinion sharply, and both sides have a point. Used well a crate is a genuine benefit; used badly it is confinement, and the difference is entirely in how it is introduced and how long the dog spends in it.

What is the argument for crates?

That dogs benefit from a defined space of their own where they are never disturbed, and many will choose to use one if the door is left open.

Practically, crates help enormously with toilet training, since most dogs avoid soiling where they sleep. They keep a puppy safe from hazards when it cannot be supervised, and they provide a secure place during house moves, building work, fireworks or recovery from surgery.

A dog already comfortable in a crate copes far better with veterinary hospitalisation, boarding and travel, all of which involve confinement whether the dog is used to it or not.

What is the argument against?

That crates are frequently used for convenience rather than for the dog, and that some dogs spend far too long in them.

The den analogy is also weaker than often claimed. Wild canids use dens for whelping rather than as a permanent retreat, and no dog naturally chooses a space it cannot leave.

A crate used as punishment, or one a frightened dog is shut into, causes real distress. Crating a dog with separation anxiety usually makes it considerably worse and can lead to injury as it tries to escape.

What makes a crate acceptable?

Three things. It is introduced positively so the dog chooses to go in. The door is open most of the time so it functions as a bed rather than a cage. And time inside is genuinely limited.

It should never be used as punishment. A dog sent to its crate in anger learns that the crate predicts something bad, which undoes the entire point.

How long is too long?

For an adult dog, a few hours at a time is a reasonable maximum, and not repeatedly through the day. Overnight is acceptable for a dog comfortable with it, provided it can get out if it needs to toilet.

Puppies cannot hold their bladder long and need taking out overnight. A rough guide is that a puppy can manage roughly one hour per month of age during the day, which is short.

A dog crated all day while the household is at work and again all night is confined for the great majority of its life, and that is not a defensible arrangement whatever the training.

What size should it be?

Large enough for the dog to stand fully upright without ducking, turn round comfortably and lie stretched out on its side.

Buy for adult size with a divider for a puppy, since too much space makes toilet training harder. Too small is a welfare problem rather than an inconvenience.

Do all dogs need one?

No. Plenty of dogs live entirely happily without a crate, using an open bed instead. It is a tool rather than a requirement.

Some dogs never accept one, particularly rescue dogs with a history of confinement. Forcing the issue with these dogs is counterproductive, and a bed in a quiet corner achieves most of the same benefit.

What is the honest conclusion?

A well-introduced crate that a dog uses voluntarily, for limited periods, is a positive thing. A crate used to contain a dog for most of the day is not, and calling it a den does not change that.

What are the alternatives?

A puppy pen gives more room than a crate while still containing the dog, and suits households wanting containment without a closed box.

Baby gates across a doorway restrict a dog to one safe room while allowing it to see and hear the household. For many adult dogs this achieves everything a crate would.

A defined bed in a quiet corner, with the household trained to leave the dog alone there, gives a dog its own space with no confinement at all. That is the arrangement most adult dogs end up with.